Intellij IDEA setting for "method call argument:s chop down if long" misbehaving

Question

Whenever I call a method that has too many arguments and the line exceeds the margin, I need it to put each of the params on separate lines.

My settings:

Original code:

return getSubscriptionList(contractNumber, objects, acceptLanguage, userNumber, bankSystem, groupIdentification).stream()
        .map(subscription -> createSubscriptionListItem(subscription,accountsFilterItems))
        .collect(Collectors.toList());

After reformatting (this changes it exactly to what I want):

return getSubscriptionList(
        contractNumber,
        objects,
        acceptLanguage,
        userNumber,
        bankSystem,
        groupIdentification
).stream()
        .map(subscription -> createSubscriptionListItem(subscription, accountsFilterItems))
        .collect(Collectors.toList());

After reformatting the already reformatted code again:

return getSubscriptionList(contractNumber,
        objects,
        acceptLanguage,
        userNumber,
        bankSystem,
        groupIdentification
).stream()
        .map(subscription -> createSubscriptionListItem(subscription, accountsFilterItems))
        .collect(Collectors.toList());

Why does it change the format the second time, and how can I change my settings to fix it?

Link to settings XML export